Showing posts with label RS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RS. Show all posts

Friday, 21 September 2012

Road Test: Renault Megane RS Trophy


Price as tested: €39,000 (approx)

+ Sublime chassis, massive poke, price
– Cheap cabin fittings, needs a racetrack to fully exploit
= Best hot hatch of the year. Possibly ever



It should all be bang-crash-wallop. Stuffing a massively powerful engine under the bonnet of a family hatchback, and then lowering and stiffening it while garnishing it with a side order of tyres so low in profile that they resemble watch straps should be a recipe for excitement tinged with acute discomfort.

But the Renault Megane RS Trophy is simply not like that, and that is a verdict drawn from driving it on the most challenging, bumpy and poorly maintained road surfaces that Ireland has to offer.

Renault has a long and glittering career of producing the finest hot hatches behind it, from the mousy-looking R19 16v through the fabulous Clio Williams and up to recent gems like the current Clio RS 200 and the previous generation Megane R.26. But the Megane Trophy could yet turn out to be the shiniest gem of the lot. It uses a 2.0-litre turbocharged four cylinder engine with 265bhp and 360Nm of torque which is, remarkably, more efficient in both consumption and emissions (claimed 8.2-litres per 100km and 190g/km of Co2) than its less powerful predecessor.

What had me assuming that it would be a desperately uncompromising and uncomfortable track-day special was the fact that it holds the production car lap record at the Nurburgring. Cars tweaked for the ‘Ring tend not to do so well when bumps, cambers and other traffic are introduced to the equation. IN fact cars tweaked at and for the ‘Rinfg tend to annoy me an utterly astonishing amount by, on bumpy proper roads, being undriveable, harsh-riding dens of awfulness that I just can’t wait to get out of. The Trophy proved me so, so wrong though.

Climb aboard and you get the standard Megane cabin (which is fine if nothing more) upgraded with fabulous Recaro bucket seats which hug without squeezing. The rev counter is, Ferrari style, painted bright yellow and there’s a plaque on the centre console informing that this particular car is number 21 in the series. It’s comfy and I, someone who likes the occasional almod crossiant, really appreciated the extra bit of space and give in the buckets. Far too many sports seats are just constrictive and uncomfortable. Like all Meganes, space in the back is good and the boot is a decent size too. Do you care? Thought not. On with the driving experience...

The steering, although short on real feedback, is beautifully weighted and positive and as soon as the Trophy is rolling just gives you this terrific feeling of meatiness and control. We may have lost true road feel in the switch from hydrualic to electric power steering but RenaultSport has proven with this rack that you can still mkae fake feel good.

The ride, even with those 35-section 235 Bridgestones on 19” wheels, feels remarkably supple. On the motorway, with cruise engaged, the Megane is a refined and comfortable cruiser. This isn’t supposed to be in the script.

Find a road with more twists and it really comes to life. Front grip is simply remarkable, allowing you to carry speed safely through all but the tightest corners, while that steering weight gives you something to lean against as you choose your line. The Brembo brakes are strong and delay the onset of anti-lock remarkably well, even on slippery surfaces, but ultimately never give you that I’ve-just-hit-a-brick-wall that the best performance car brakes give you. Pity that and a pity too that the silly drilled metal pedals are too slippy and act as a bit of a confidence drain.
What brings back the confidence is the Megane’s poise. The way it reacts to direction changes is utterly brilliant. I have a quiet stretch of road to test such things (no, I’m not telling you where it is) and never have I driven anything that deals quite so will with a particular bit of off-camber approach, sudden direction-change tarmac as the Trophy.

 That 6.0sec 0-100kmh time allows you to sprint away from tight junctions, with the tractions control juddering away to keep the front tyres in play.

But it’s the ride that really impresses. It’s certainly not soft, but it feels remarkably well tuned for Irish roads, shrugging off lumps and scars on the road with a relaxed gait, while still giving you the sort of iron-fisted body control that you really need to be able to enjoy a good drive. Honestly, I don’t know how Renault has managed to get such a fast car to be so comfy. Witchcraft, perhaps?

The only slight let down is, surprisingly, the engine itself. Yes it’s powerful, and makes a nice roar at the top end, but it’s only at that top end that you really feel the power. That big turbo only really starts puffing at 4.500rpm and it’s all over at 6,000rpm.  It’s not slow below the 4,500rpm mark, far from it, but you only get the big guns firing once you stretch it past this point and by that time, you’re already going so quickly that, on the public road, you’re not really going to stretch it any farther. Bigger fireworks lower down the rev range, even if they compromised ultimate grunt, would make the Trophy a little more enjoyably unruly. The noise is good, a bassy bellow that encourages further listening, but again it’s all happening in the final 1,000rpm. Lower down, the refinement is welcome on a long journey but you do crave a bit more aural entertainment.

But the price. Renault Ireland has still to set a final price for the Trophy, but circa €39,000 makes it one of the performance bargains of the decade. Honestly. The Megane Trophy is so useable, so easy to get the best from, so biddable and such gloriously good fun to drive that you really are talking about buying cars costing three, four even five times as much before you’re into something that you can honestly say is a quantifiably faster way to cover tarmac miles. If Renault had added €20k to the price, we’d still have called it good. As it is, barely any more expensive than a specced up Golf GTI, it is an utter legend.

Facts & Figures:
Renault Megane RS Trophy
Price as tested: €39,000 (approx)
Price range: €18,890 to €39,000 (approx)
Capacity: 1,998cc
Power: 265bhp
Torque: 360Nm
Top speed: 254kmh
0-100kmh: 6.0sec
Economy: 8.2l-100km (34.8mpg)
CO2 emissions: 190g/km
Road Tax Band: E €630
Euro NCAP rating: 5-star adult, 4-star child, 2-star pedestrian











Road Test: Renault Clio RS Gordini


Price as tested: €28,000 (approx)

+ Scalpel-sharp chassis and steering, characterful engine
– Silly paint job, high Co2
= A purist’s hot hatch

Quite why Renault has chosen to revive the old Gordini name for its hot hatch range is a little baffling, to me at least. OK, so there’s the connection with the classic R8 Gordini, some sixties Le Mans cars and, not least, the original fifties Gordini F1 team. But, looking back at Gordini’s F1 record, it’s hard to ignore that aside from a couple of thirds for legendary charger Jean Behra, the team’s record was one of lower placings and retirements. Which is why I’m puzzled. After all, Renault already has the RenaultSport brand, which has won mulitple F1 world championships as both an engine maker and a team, has won the Le Mans 24hrs and the Monte Carlo rally. So why go to the bother of resurrecting a racing name that few have ever heard of?

Especially when, applied to the Clio 200 RS, the Gordini name seems to signify little more than some sparkly blue paint, some silly stripes and some blue inserts in the cabin. Amedee Gordini’s signature is conspicuous by its absence and there are no mechanical changes to the chassis or engine.

Then again, there didn’t need to be. The Clio RS has been THE reference small hot hatch for some years now, providing the sort of razor sharp thrills that once seemed to have been outlawed, or at least forgotten about. And while I’d aver that that crown has slipped a little (we’ll come to more of that in a minute) this is still a properly thrilling little car to drive.

It is, in a way, quite old-fashioned. There are no turbos here, no clever downsizing. Just a big (2.0-litre, with 200bhp and 215Nm of torque) engine stuffed into a relatively small, light car. There are hot camshafts, improved breathing and all the classic techniques for getting more grunt out of a simple engine.

That lack (if that’s the right word) of a turbo means that the Clio RS is quite unforgiving. There’s enough torque to pootle around happily at low speeds, and the gearing is so short that even sixth on the wonderfully notchy-feeling gearbox won’t bog down around town. No, if you want to feel what the Clio is really capable of, you have to rev it. By 3,00rpm it’s starting to move, and starting to fart angrily down the exhaust too. By 4,500 that fart has grown in intensity and is now really roaring. But you sense that there’s still more, much more, to come. And you’re right. Get the needle moving about 5,000rpm, get the engine onto the cam properly and things really start to move. By now the Clio is bursting with energy, ripping through its last 3,000rpm to the redline and you’re seriously moving. So grab another gear, drop back down the rev range and begin again. 0-100kmh is done in 6.9secs, should you wish.

The problem is, and this is where the Clio starts to wobble a little atop its throne, is that while having such a highly tuned, high-revving engine is wonderful, it does bring with it some limitations. The chief one of which is that you have to drive it like you’re in your own personal Le Mans to get the most out of it, which is hardly a practical, or even law abiding, state of affairs. Its turbocharged rivals may not have the true, spine-tingling feel of the Clio at high rpm, but their torquey, low-down oomph is more suited to the quick-thrill-and-then-relax driving style so necessary in these heavily regulated times.

It doesn’t do the running costs any favour either. Renault claims 8.2-litres per 100km on average, we managed 10.1l/100km, thanks to some (ahem) enthusiastic driving. The Co2 figure of 196g/km doesn’t look to clever either, especially when you consider that a Mini Cooper S Works manages 164g/km.

But where the Clio really starts to make up for all this is when you get it on to a twisty road. Now, a small, light car with big wheels and low profile tyres is hardly going to prove a perfect match for Irish back roads, and so it proves as the Clio hops and skips its way along. But the way this thing steers is where the real gold is to be found. That steering is just alive, flowing with information and perfect weighting, in an era when even the best supercars have numb, over-assisted tillers. There is still that slight whiff of unnatural self-centering, but that apart, this is not so much a car as a tool for deconstructing the geometry of the road builder’s art. Tightening apexes, sudden changes of direction, long, fast sweepers; all are a playground for the Clio’s talents.

The rest of the chassis backs that up. You’d have to be clinically insane to be going fast enough to get it to slide or slip, but there is still a sense of adjustability. It’s not just a point and squirt car. Once you get into the meat of a corner, you’re not just waiting for the apex to come and go before opening the throttle again. The Clio gives you options. Tighten the line to give oncoming traffic a wider berth. Let the nose run a little wide to avoid an errant tree root. Or just stick to your chosen line as if the tyres were covered in PrittStick and blast out the other side with a massive grin on your face.

The rest of the Clio fits neatly into the classic hot hatch playbook. Spacious cabin, comfy seats that support without squeezing too hard (even if the driving position is all over the place). A decent boot and a sense of decent build quality, even if some of the materials used simply don’t look or feel up to the task.

I have to admit to a slight, lingering sense of disappointment about the Clio Gordini too. It’s not the colour scheme, with its silly stripes (all car makers succumb, sooner or later, to such needless theatrics). It’s not the fact that you have to wring the engine so hard to truly experience its magic. It’s not the jiggly ride or the offset pedals. It’s actually a comparison to its bigger brother. The Megane RS Trophy (full road test HERE) is only around €10,000 more expensive. I say only, but there is a serious point here. Whereas the Clio stands in comparison to the likes of the Citroen DS3 Racing, the VW Polo GTI and the upcoming Ford Fiesta ST, the Megane is something else again. It is a spacious, comfy, practical hot hatch that bears serious comparison with seven-figure supercars in its ability to cover ground. It is on another planet entirely.

So while I loved driving the Clio, and would recommend it as a tonic for the ills of the modern motoring world, perhaps I made a mistake. I shouldn’t have driven its bigger brother first.


Facts & Figures

Renault Clio Gordini RS
Price as tested: €28,000 (approx)
Range price: TBC
Capacity: 1,997cc
Power: 201bhp
Torque: 215Nm
Top speed: 225kmh
0-100kmh: 6.9sec
Economy: 8.2l-100km (34.6mpg)
CO2 emissions: 196g/km
VRT Band: F. €1,050 road tax
Euro NCAP rating: 5-star adult, 4-star child, 1-star pedestrian